Well, if you're looking for "old school" Magic Castle decks, go REALLY old school and get the ones from USPC. Someone wrote a good article on here a while back about the Magic Castle decks in the old design - you should search for it. The final printing of that design was from Cartamundi and isn't even worth the paper it's printed on - the cards have a plasticky feel to them and have a terrible habit of clumping together badly after very little use. The USPC ones are HARD to find - many of those decks were bought up and either hoarded by collectors/tourists or used by magicians. There were a few other print runs from other companies, as I recall - to my knowledge, it's the Cartamundi ones that aren't worth the time of day.
Darn it. I was hoping it wouldn't come to that. Personally, I hold older generations of cards to a high standard, given how decks like the Studs, Aristocrats, Tahoes, Nuggets, and Magic Castle decks all managed to capture the attention of the great card men of that era.
Maybe I'm just buying the hype of "they used it, so I should too", but even today, I have a huge frustration with modern Bikes. I live in a place with humidity, so they generate "clicks" insanely fast, and even then, the quality of the cut isn't all that great. The registers are off, the sides feel like sand paper, and they just don't hold up like I need them too.
Honestly, this is why I invest in more expensive playing cards. Dan and Dave (albeit extremely expensive now that they've shifted sites), put out some GREAT decks of cards, even though they cost twice as much. The Dealing Deuces reprints were also great cards, and I'm actually wondering if people would be interested in a reprint of the old Black and Inverse designs that DD brought out several years ago.
I actually wanted to ask your opinion on this, Don. What do you think about cards today? Do you remember the quality that used to be put out? What do you think companies like Dan & Dave and Conjuring Arts are doing that makes their decks that much better?