Hey all! I'm an old school kind of guy, so while I'm sure there is a Facebook group or something for this, I can't resist the archived knowledge of a forum. I've been collecting decks for a few years now and I'm looking forward to reading all about what you guys have tracked down. My dream would be to have a wall of cards that just runs through every deck from Ellusionist and Theory 11, but that is clearly going to take a long time. I just think it would make fantastic decoration. Right now I just have one wall display that holds 60 or so decks and that seems to do the trick to display my sealed ones that have meaning.
I do have a little bit of OCD, so card collecting is a challenge. When I find out that there are different versions or variations of a deck, I have to have them all. This has gotten expensive at times and I'm really trying to control it now. Especially when some of these decks run 40 or 50 bucks (or more!) to get the variation/version I'm missing. I did just pick up a sealed v1 Black Ghost that I'm pretty pleased with, but now I'm on the hunt for a v2 white ghost to finish that series off. I'm trying to find an Ohio printed blue deck for the Bicycle 1800 cards too.
Actually, if anyone reads this, I have a question on those. How can you tell if you have the marked version or unmarked version without opening the deck? For example, I have an Ohio and KY version of the red deck, but I have no idea which one is marked. I don't know if anyone does, so even looking online to buy them is tricky because none of the sellers on ebay seem to know this was even a marked deck at all.
Anyway, good to be here and if anyone is in the DFW area and wants to talk cards, hit me up! I'd love to know where you are finding yours. I have a great source of cards up in McKinney from a guy I met on ebay if you are looking for recommendations.
Hi, and sorry for the late reply!
Re White Ghost - As far as I know, Ellusionist made only one version of the Bicycle White Ghost deck. Black Ghost came first, and was originally only available as a giveaway for celebrity magicians, then was a premium for making certain purchases - V2 came when V1 became really popular and people clamored to buy them. White Ghost, never being made as a premium like the Black Ghost V1, only ever came in a single version. Some people might get fussy about "oh, but what about this slight change from one print one to the next?", but you can drive yourself insane chasing different print runs, and there's no reliable publicly-available records of their print runs - you'd have to buy Ellusionist to know, and even that wouldn't guarantee it!
As far as marked and unmarked versions of a deck - it really depends on the deck. I'm assuming you're referring to decks that were printed as marked at the factory. Most often, there's some additional packaging around the deck when it's sold to indicate it's a marked deck, then the tuck box itself has nothing to indicate whether it's marked or not. For example, GT Speedreaders are a popular marked deck made with the Bicycle Mandolin Back, and they're wrapped in cellophane that clearly describes them as a marked deck, while the tuck box inside that cellophane is the same as all the other Bicycle Mandolin Back decks. If you have marked decks that somehow lost that outer packaging, well - you'd have no way to know without opening it.
In cases where there's no additional wrapping or other indications in the packaging, oftentimes that's because the deck itself only comes in a marked version. An example of this would be Cohorts from Ellusionist - there's no unmarked version, they're all marked. The very first Legends deck from Legends Playing Cards is another example - all of them are marked, in all three colors, if I recall.
There's an interesting caveat - Bicycle Rider Backs, or Bicycle Standard as they're more commonly known these days due to a packaging change. Not long after USPC moved from Cincinnati to Erlanger, their legal department noticed an intellectual property problem. Most of their artwork for their classic decks is no longer protected under copyrights, having been made too long ago to still be copyrighted. While they can't trademark playing cards themselves, they were able to trademark the unique elements of their decks, such as back design, jokers and Ace of Spades. While copyright law is a little liberal when it comes to creating derivative works, trademark law is a lot tighter when it comes to protecting those trademarks - allowing variations to exist in the marketplace amounts to "dilution" of the trademark, which results in rendering the trademark unenforceable.
So they stopped accepting variations from the standard designs on those elements, which included various gaffed cards and marked decks. The legal team went back and forth a few times over what was permitted and what wasn't - for a while, Ellusionist was allowed to keep making Series 1800 decks (regular and marked), until they weren't, because one of their lawyers thought the fake weathering/aging effect was an unacceptable alteration, forcing them to create Series 1900 decks - a similar-looking design (and marked) but with the markings hidden in the border. But even that was considered too much, and E was told by USPC they couldn't print more. The legal team tends to waver a bit now and then, but by and large, if you have a Bicycle Standard deck that was printed around 2010 or later, it's probably not marked. (A pair of French magicians did sneak in a print run of the Ultimate Marked Deck, but those are pretty scarce and these days are very expensive, so it's less likely that someone will confuse it for an unmarked pack.) The only new development on that front was from Ondrej Psenicka - in 2023, he released a Bicycle Rider Back deck with a simple border design surrounding the bog-standard Rider Back image, and hidden in the border is a non-reader, binary-based marking system. Aside from this thin red line with white stripes, the rest of the back design is completely, totally the standard design, and USPC gave it a green light.
Beyond that, if you wanted to make a recently-printed marked deck, you'd need a unique card design of your own, or you'd need to create it in one of their newer backs that they market to magicians looking for alterable backs - those being the Mandolin Back and the Maiden Back. In market tests, the vast majority of consumers didn't notice any difference between those and the Rider Backs. I even know of magicians who placed gaffed Mandolin and Maiden Back cards into a Rider Back deck, and their audiences never caught on because the average person (even ones attending magic shows) simply don't notice and remember enough of the design details to distinguish between them.