OK, I'll grant you that it's a "lazy reprint" and everything. At least from what people think right now. Before the deck's even been released.
Who knows? Imagine Steamboats with Bee Casino stock and Magic Finish - what would that be like, compared to the original? Perhaps the artwork is classic reproductions of an earlier version of the deck.
I'm not a big fan of a lot of what D&D have done recently with playing cards, and that's no secret. (Ace Fulton's Strip Joint, anyone? It comes in peach, dark brown and caramel...) But this is something they're doing in concert with USPC, much like the T11 decks that USPC carries. Think of it - while Steam Punk didn't exactly wow anyone, Guardians and Archangels are some pretty good decks. This could end up being a great redesign of a classic, with the benefit of updated finish.
My point is that we're all quick to judge a product that we've only seen inside its tuck box.
Anyone got a release time on this yet?
I have to disagree for a couple reasons. Although I agree that it's a bit early to judge because it's POSSIBLE that they can surprise us and recreate it with some new, "meant to be like the original" stock, I very highly doubt it.
1) Steamboats with bee Casino and Magic finish... See, that's just it, you can print any deck with that stock and finish. So with the current technology and creative standards, why would you do it on a deck with a sub-par, borderless back design that's useless for magic and has no uniqueness in any other aspect of the deck/design.
2) The Steamboats had very nice stock, stiff and thin. Like alex said, USPCC just does not have those papers available anymore. So since the only legitimate appeal to the deck was it's handling due to that great stock, reprinting it WITHOUT that is useless.
Warning, stupidly impromptu analogy: I think it could be compared to pea soup. Pea soup basically looks like vomit...Yuck! So why do people eat it? Because they like peas maybe.. or maybe just because the peas make it taste unique and good. In either case, the peas are the focal point of their interests.
D&D are basically remaking making this, quite gross looking pea soup (steamboats), without the peas (their stock), that just tastes like regular ol' chicken noodle.Lawl, I can't believe I just related playing cards to soup. I'm impressed. Can I get a badge for that? I think yes.
Again, this is all speculation, but based on D&D's history, even if they do make changes to this deck they will be minute and these points will still stand.