I will start with my opinion and then explain it
I don't like this deck
I don't feel that the artwork taken from a fantastic source is done any kind of Justice.
It feels crammed in. And as far as the concept of a dreary alternate universe... This is created by a spot of blood and the cards being "muddied up"
I was so happy when this was cancelled the first time. Now that it is back, with so many days to reach it's goal, I fear that it may succeed.
I don't say this out of spite but out of the fact that I would love to see a decent deck made using the same artwork and if this succeeds no one would try it.
As far as a darker American McGees Alice, I know Shane tyree was working on a darker deck when he was with Albino dragon. They were going to do that one and for some reason they decided to go with the straight version with "White Rabbit". Which I was ok with as it was a nice deck... however he used the darker version of the Cheshire cat he created which I didn't feel went with the whole feel.
I contacted Erik after the campaign ended (but before Shane got the boot and asked if they would be doing the darker version, at the time he said they would)
But I digress