OK, my take on this.
- I like the art. It's fun and quirky.
- The indices are functional, if a bit dull. Dull, however, isn't necessarily a bad thing on an index.
- He made some really custom pips - then only used them on the Aces! What a shame.
- I always prefer a joker with an index of some kind, but that's just me. It could work without one just as well.
- There is no way on this green Earth that USPC will allow those borders on the backs to remain that thin. I don't think there's enough room between the edge of the design and the cut line of the card for a fart, never mind a border! USPC simply isn't capable of the kind of precision registration and alignment needed to accurately cut the cards without being off-center enough to ruin the backs. They WILL send him back to the drawing board.
- I also feel he low-balled the goal - unless he's kicking in his own cash, I think he's going to have a tough time delivering what's promised, especially if he barely makes it over his goal.
OMG...With such good artwork, i felt there could really be more going on for this deck.
Like what Don said. He had some nice custom pips going on, why only use it on the Aces? As for the court cards, i felt he could just leave out the borders and have the courts a little larger, or at least have a more detailed border. It feels like so much effort was put into the pips and court images, but non was done for the overall aesthetic of the cards.
The artwork is definitely something worth pledging, but i think it still needs more fine-tuning.
(Read 1266 times)
