It feels a little too baroque to me. Consider what the authentic badges of the old West looked like. A few had some ornate details, a few were absolutely covered in detail work, but the vast majority were very simple affairs, way less elaborate than what you're presenting here. This might be a case where less is more.
Thanks for the feedback Don, So you still prefer B2 from the previous post? This will be a tough choice for me 
I have been getting good and less good feedback on both styles.
Well, in the end, you're the artist and the call is yours to make!
Try an experiment. Make the simplest, most utterly stripped-down version of a six-pointed sheriff's badge you can, with as few details as possible. Gradually add new, simple elements, one at a time, and look at the overall appearance with each new addition. At some point, you'll hit that sweet spot that looks just right to your sensibilities - some level of detail without being overly-adorned, lending the design a more authentic feel.
But before you even start, do an image search for Old West-style lawman badges and you'll get an idea of what I'm talking about when it comes to the simplicity of most of the designs. Many were as simple as a hunk of metal shaped into a star or a shield with a few words engraved or stamped into them and that was it - they were in many cases perhaps the work of the local blacksmith rather than the local engraver, silversmith or jeweler, considering nearly all frontier towns would have the former but relatively few would have any of the latter! Fancy silver or metalwork would be the kind of thing you'd have to go to a larger town or city to find.
Remember, the replica badges a lot of sites will show you are representative of what was out there, often labeled with the names of cities you've heard of either in history books or in the modern day, but a lot of the actual badges of that time period were made for a lawman in some dinky, one-horse town consisting of "main street" and little else, a town that may no longer even exists. It would say "sheriff," the town name and that's about it. In more dangerous territories, it was a pretty thankless position and fraught with risk, especially if you happened to be the one officer of the law in a hole-in-the-wall town buried in the middle of nowhere, a place rife with lawlessness because it made for a convenient, out-of-the-way place to hide. There are stories of entire towns that were literally controlled by bandits, rustlers and other lawbreakers without a lawman in sight, the town's entire
raison d'être being to serve as a hideout.
