You are Here:
Beginner collector here, just saying hello

Author (Read 1345 times)

Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« on: October 29, 2016, 07:26:26 PM »
 

shaitani

  • 52 Plus Joker Member
  • Newcomer
  • *
  • 6
    Posts
  • Reputation: 2
Hello everyone, my name is Hagop, I'm from Southern California, USA.

I'm new to the forums and new to collecting playing cards.

I've been a part time collector of lots of different things over the years. Tools, knives, posters, coins, cards, pretty much everything.
I recently got into collecting decks because of the crazy explosion of artists working in this area on some amazing looking pieces and I wanted in!

Most of my pieces tend to be "safe-queens" so I don't open maybe 98% of the decks I buy, even the extras I buy convincing myself I'll open and play with for once, I never do. Maybe that speaks to my ocd, but that's my thing. Any time I want to learn some basic cardistry move, I'll usually use a more standard bicycle deck.

Anyway, I'll probably explore the forum in due time, but in the mean time, anything I should know about this place? Popular threads/subforums? Any etiquette besides the basics I should familiarize myself with?
« Last Edit: October 29, 2016, 07:33:47 PM by shaitani »
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #1 on: October 30, 2016, 01:37:42 AM »
 

HankMan

  • 52 Plus Joker Member
  • Discourse Royalty
  • *
  • 453
    Posts
  • Reputation: 13
Hi Hagop welcome to the forum  :D

This place is one of the best forum for playing cards. You can pretty much search for anything from Antique to Modern deck.
Dont be afraid to ask if you have any questions, there are many collectors here that have tons of knowledge and they do like to share.

Back for more
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #2 on: October 30, 2016, 03:24:49 AM »
 

Don Boyer

  • VP/Dir. Club Forum/DAC Chair, 52 Plus Joker
  • Administrator
  • Forum Sentinel
  • *
  • 19,172
    Posts
  • Reputation: 415
  • Pick a card, any card...no, not THAT card!

  • Facebook:
Hey there, Hagop - welcome to the forum!

I get what you're saying about saving your decks.  Most cardists will practice with standard packs like Bicycles and Bees because they're cheaper and more plentiful than collectible decks.  There are also some good decks made in "unlimited" quantities from a few magic/playing cards companies that are slightly better in quality and still reasonably priced - a good example would be the NOC deck V3 series by the Blue Crown.

There are some collectors around here that actually buy decks less for their contents, more for the fact that they like the packaging and have a thing about getting complete sets!  If that makes them happy, it's their cash, right?  Having said that, my personal preference is to buy two decks - one to open and enjoy, one to save.  I do a little magic performing, and I mostly won't use rare/scarce collectible or limited edition decks for that anymore - I've ruined enough of them to learn that magic performed for an audience is hard on a deck of cards!  I generally will perform with decks that I know are still in print and not terribly expensive.  I also look for decks that are fairly standard in their design - some people say that audiences will think a totally custom deck will become suspect as a "magic deck," which I think is baloney, but I find that using a deck with at least mostly-standard faces will be less distracting to my audience and allows them to identify with the cards I'm using ("Gee, I have cards a lot like those at home...").  There's a certain irony to that thought about custom decks being suspect - the vast majority of all magic decks out there are made using the most common design in the United States - the Bicycle Rider Back!  If anything, they should suspect a standard-looking deck that's seemingly innocuous - but they rarely do!  Even opening the pack in front of them is no guarantee - I've become skilled at carefully removing the cellophane wrapper and reusing it to seal a deck and I have spare USPC deck sticker seals!

As far as forum etiquette, it's pretty easygoing around here.  The big rules of thumb are "post something meaningful," as in avoiding spam, "I wish I could afford that" or "me, too" posts that don't really add to the conversation, and "do unto others as you would have them do unto you," as in simply being polite to each other.  Genuine-article rudeness around here is exceptionally rare and highly frowned-upon.  Use search to try and answer a question before creating a new topic - it's possible that your question was previously asked and answered.  But if it wasn't answered already or you can't find it, ask away - we don't haze the newbies and the question you ask is probably on the minds of other people looking for answers as well!
Card Illusionist, NYC Area
Playing Card Design & Development Consultant
Deck Tailoring: Custom Alterations for Magicians and Card Mechanics
Services for Hire - http://thedecktailor.com/
Pre-Made Decks for Sale - http://donboyermagic.com/
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #3 on: October 30, 2016, 03:57:01 PM »
 

shaitani

  • 52 Plus Joker Member
  • Newcomer
  • *
  • 6
    Posts
  • Reputation: 2
Thank you for the welcomes, I'm glad to be here.

Don, thank you for all the advice and your thoughts, very much appreciated. The "plan" I have in my head is, 'wait until you're good enough to avoid destroying the decks before you open and play with decks worth more than $5'. Which, is a good plan theoretically, but that day when I'm "good enough" will keep getting pushed further away. I mean, I destroyed a few standards before I was good enough with the Faro to NOT obliterate the edges of a deck, so in that sense it was smart. But on the other hand, now I'm waiting until I'm good enough with the Lepaul spread not to leave an asymmetric bend in the cards (if that's even possible). Sooo it's an ongoing quest.

For the time being, yes I'm one of those people who spends my cash on pleasing looking decks and complete sets. I even buy decks I know I never want to open, like the current Titans Kickstarter deck for example. I very much dislike the faces of the cards, but I love the backs and I love the tuck boxes. So I burned $52 on that set of all three.

As for your comment on performances using common vs custom decks, I never planned to perform anything in front of others so I never thought about that. But what you're saying makes absolute sense, seeing something common puts people at ease oddly. I guess I hope that one day custom decks will start becoming common enough in magic performances that people stop relating it to trickery by association. That way we get to see some deck diversity.

On that note, what percentage of custom decks right now do you think are marked? I never open decks enough to find out, but I do know there are a number of them which are definitely marked. Like, I'm pretty sure all (most?) of the Madison decks are marked. So I'm sure other decks do it too, but I don't really have a good idea of how many.
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #4 on: November 01, 2016, 03:04:28 AM »
 

Don Boyer

  • VP/Dir. Club Forum/DAC Chair, 52 Plus Joker
  • Administrator
  • Forum Sentinel
  • *
  • 19,172
    Posts
  • Reputation: 415
  • Pick a card, any card...no, not THAT card!

  • Facebook:
Thank you for the welcomes, I'm glad to be here.

Don, thank you for all the advice and your thoughts, very much appreciated. The "plan" I have in my head is, 'wait until you're good enough to avoid destroying the decks before you open and play with decks worth more than $5'. Which, is a good plan theoretically, but that day when I'm "good enough" will keep getting pushed further away. I mean, I destroyed a few standards before I was good enough with the Faro to NOT obliterate the edges of a deck, so in that sense it was smart. But on the other hand, now I'm waiting until I'm good enough with the Lepaul spread not to leave an asymmetric bend in the cards (if that's even possible). Sooo it's an ongoing quest.

For the time being, yes I'm one of those people who spends my cash on pleasing looking decks and complete sets. I even buy decks I know I never want to open, like the current Titans Kickstarter deck for example. I very much dislike the faces of the cards, but I love the backs and I love the tuck boxes. So I burned $52 on that set of all three.

As for your comment on performances using common vs custom decks, I never planned to perform anything in front of others so I never thought about that. But what you're saying makes absolute sense, seeing something common puts people at ease oddly. I guess I hope that one day custom decks will start becoming common enough in magic performances that people stop relating it to trickery by association. That way we get to see some deck diversity.

On that note, what percentage of custom decks right now do you think are marked? I never open decks enough to find out, but I do know there are a number of them which are definitely marked. Like, I'm pretty sure all (most?) of the Madison decks are marked. So I'm sure other decks do it too, but I don't really have a good idea of how many.

Re performance with custom decks, it's not about people thinking they're trick decks.  They usually don't.  It's a bit of a myth among some that custom equals trick deck in the minds of spectators.  Actually, the bigger issue is that when you perform with a trick deck, even if it isn't some special limited edition, the more interesting and unique the deck's appearance is, the more your spectator will be focusing on the cards and not on the trick!  For some, that might work as a form of misdirection, if your object is to do something elsewhere while there's all googly-eyed looking at the cards, but for most, when the spectator isn't paying attention to the trick much at all, there's less of an impact when you finally pull off "the prestige" at the end.

Cardists have noticed this as well and many will actually opt for a fairly simple design over an attractive custom design - but that's more of a preference thing for cardists, since there's no trick being performed and the cards are indeed integral to what the cardist is doing.  Some look for a middle ground of sorts - a deck with fairly standard faces but with backs intentionally designed to make for more attractive flourishes, such as the Virtuoso deck series produced by the cardist team of the Virts.

As far as decks being marked, particularly custom decks, the number is much smaller than you think.  Not all Madison decks are marked, though it's true that many are - his deck series probably has more marked decks than almost every other.  Only a very small number, perhaps a few percent, are actually marked.  It can actually hurt sales to sell a marked deck to the general public.  Poker players, not wanting to be accused of cheating, won't even touch a one-way back design, never mind a deck that's known to be marked.

Plus, there are a variety of ways a deck can be marked.  There are factory-printed markings and "homemade" markings.  There are markings visible to the naked eye and markings that require a special method to become visible, such as using a filter-equipped pair of sunglasses or defocusing your eyes.  There are markings that are well-suited for card games (usually when the marking system is confined to the upper-left corner and its inverse, because that's the corner visible in a card player's hand when the cards are held fanned) and markings that are poorly-suited for card games (the NOC decks from version 2 forward have either full markings or suit-only markings, depending on the exact model, but the markings require that you be able to see the entire card back to be read).  There are markings that require memorizing some kind of system or code to be read and there are markings that are written in plainly-readable ways (usually letters, numbers and possibly suit symbols) if you know exactly where to look in the card's back design.  (Decks using plainly-readable markings are sometimes called "readers" for this reason.  Readers have to be well-designed to keep their marks hidden - if not, even a casual examination of a single card's back will reveal the markings.)

The different systems fit different purposes - a system ideal for a card player might not be as good for a magician, since people familiar with card marking might look in the ideal places that card cheats would use to mark cards for readability in one's hand.

There's even a marked deck out there that has zero markings of any kind externally - the cards are factory printed with RFID chips in them, making them readable using a tiny chip reader you can wear on your wrist or conceal in a tuck box.  It can tell you what a specific card is by two methods - either by vibrating against your wrist in a pattern to tell you value and suit, or by using a Bluetooth-connected smartphone equipped with their reader app, but you have to be within Bluetooth range of the reader - typically not more than about three or four yards, depending on the local environment.  You don't even need to see the card itself to know the value and suit, as long as it's within range of the reader (within inches) and the rest of the deck is far enough to not be in range - it could be in a pocket, in a sealed envelope or under a napkin or tablecloth.  It's safe to say this deck is not common at all - it's VERY expensive, running in the low three figures for the cards and all the necessary hardware and software.

If you have your hands on a deck, one of the more effective ways to spot the more detectable, visible marking systems (the types commonly used by magicians and less-sophisticated, low-tech card cheats) is to employ the riffle test, sometimes called "going to the movies."  As a kid, I'm sure you've played with or saw flip book animations - a series of drawings are sketched onto the corners of a pad's pages, each one slightly changed from the last, so when flipped, you can see the drawings "come to life" as a primitive but effective form of animation.  The riffle test employs the same principle.  Hold one end of a deck firmly while riffling the cards at the other end, just like a flip book.  In a standard deck, all the backs are identical and nothing should change, making for a very boring animation.  In a marked deck using visible markings, all the backs are different in some small way, and if you look carefully, you'll spot the changes while riffling the cards, though it might take you a few tries if the marks are particularly subtle.

I've managed to reverse-engineer the marking systems of a few decks using a modified riffle test I'd thought of - I sorted the cards into suit order first, just to see what changed at the quarter, half and three-quarter points of the deck as I riffled, then sorted them in value order with all the aces together, then the deuces together, etc., all the way to kings, then riffled to spot the subtle changes in the marks as I flipped from value to value through the cards.  If the cards are randomly mixed, all you see is little flickers happening in a random order, just as random as the order of the cards, but if you sort the cards as I described, you can more easily see the changes from suit to suit and value to value, charting the differences more easily - it's like watching a slow-motion animation where the frames remain the same for thirteen frames in a row (when looking for suit changes) or four frames in a row (when looking for value changes).

One interesting caveat, when looking for marked decks.  Due to issues regarding copyright and trademark law, the US Playing Card Company (USPC) doesn't allow modification to certain elements of their classic deck designs, most notably, the backs of their still-in-print decks which use artwork too old to be protected under copyright law.  They have to be protected as trademarks, and in doing so, the company can't allow "dilution" of the trademark by permitting variants of the trademark to exist in the marketplace.  For making marked decks or gaff cards, these would require alterations of the classic back design, which means that the company will no longer print them in designs such as the Bicycle Rider Back, the Bee Diamond Back, etc.  There are two modern Bicycle backs, both young enough to be protected by copyright - the Mandolin Back and the Maiden Back.  These were designed and tested to be similar enough to the Rider Back that most spectators won't tell the difference, but they're unique enough that they don't represent infringements or dilutions of the trademarked backs.  Gaff cards and marked decks are available in these designs and USPC will print versions of these designs that are modified, at least until those copyrights run out, but that won't be for perhaps a hundred years or more.  This also means that older, factory-marked versions of the classic designs are highly sought after and go for a significant premium over other marked decks.
« Last Edit: November 01, 2016, 03:18:58 AM by Don Boyer »
Card Illusionist, NYC Area
Playing Card Design & Development Consultant
Deck Tailoring: Custom Alterations for Magicians and Card Mechanics
Services for Hire - http://thedecktailor.com/
Pre-Made Decks for Sale - http://donboyermagic.com/
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #5 on: November 01, 2016, 02:39:17 PM »
 

shaitani

  • 52 Plus Joker Member
  • Newcomer
  • *
  • 6
    Posts
  • Reputation: 2
Very thorough response, I learned like 10 new things reading it, so thank you in advance. Forewarning about my own response here, my knowledge is obviously very limited, so I can only provide reactionary thoughts.

Regarding the custom deck performances, everything you said makes sense, I also imagine that a lot of cardistry moves are and can be used effectively in a routine for the "googly-eyed" misdirection. In conjunction with a fancy custom deck, especially with standard faces, it's the perfect distraction. It would be like watching cirque du soleil magic show. You'd have no idea how any of it is being done, but it looks beautiful and still mystifies you. I love it, and I hope magicians one day soon feel comfortable enough to use them on TV. Like I don't think I've seen anyone on Fool Us for example using anything besides a standard rider back-looking deck.

As far as markings go, I assumed if I had looked at enough of all the custom decks I've been buying I'd see in the range of 20-40% of them as marked. But it sounds like you're saying it's much lower, maybe single digits. That's good to know, because I honestly prefer that the decks are not marked. Primarily because if I were to use the custom decks it mostly likely would be to play poker and not to actually perform a trick.

All of your pieces about the markings are very illuminating for me, like I had never even heard of the RFID chips inside a card method of marking, I didn't realize that RFID could be made thin enough to even be put into a card without it being noticeable. Also thank you for the lesson on the riffle technique for identifying the marks, it's now in my arsenal.

You should definitely consider making a sticky or something for some of us rookies outlining exactly what you said here, because every paragraph breaks down the topic incredibly well. Thank you kindly for taking the time to write it.
 

Re: Beginner collector here, just saying hello
« Reply #6 on: November 01, 2016, 06:45:21 PM »
 

Don Boyer

  • VP/Dir. Club Forum/DAC Chair, 52 Plus Joker
  • Administrator
  • Forum Sentinel
  • *
  • 19,172
    Posts
  • Reputation: 415
  • Pick a card, any card...no, not THAT card!

  • Facebook:
Cardistry developed out of magic – magicians have been using flourishes to disguise other moves for many, many years! One of the most common uses would be a false shuffle or the manipulation of specific cards to a specific area of the deck under the guise of a very pretty-looking flourish.

The majority of magicians on "Penn & Teller: Fool Us" do use Bicycle Rider Back playing cards – as I've stated, there are more gaff cards and trick decks in that design that in any other design on planet Earth!  But I have also seen magicians using various different Phoenix decks as well. The Phoenix deck is produced by a German company called Card Shark, which specializes in a wide assortment of gaffs and trick decks for magicians. Some of the cards are manufactured for them by the United States Playing Card Company while others they manufacture themselves on their own private press. I've even seen one magician on Fool Us attempting, in a rather bald-faced way, to perform a trick using Phoenix Parlor cards – these are an intermediate size between poker cards and jumbo cards, large enough for a moderately-large audience to see from the back row but small enough to manipulate easily in the hands. These cards are only manufactured in a marked version with a concealed one-way mark on the back!

The cards with the hidden RFID chips are also in the Phoenix design, but I have seen them sold by Ellusionist if I'm not mistaken. The only way to successfully conceal the chips with in the cards is the do so during manufacture, not as an aftermarket modification. The chips are literally manufactured right into the cards in a way that makes them completely invisible to the naked eye and they can be handled and shuffled like most ordinary decks.

 Perhaps I will split a portion of this topic off to create a new topic and add it to our "all-time classics" board, "The Source – Card Collecting 101."
« Last Edit: November 01, 2016, 06:48:20 PM by Don Boyer »
Card Illusionist, NYC Area
Playing Card Design & Development Consultant
Deck Tailoring: Custom Alterations for Magicians and Card Mechanics
Services for Hire - http://thedecktailor.com/
Pre-Made Decks for Sale - http://donboyermagic.com/